Not Native American : Art Fakes, Replicas, and Invented Traditions

The author is Janet Catherine Berlo. The Foreword is by Joe Horse Capture, Citizen of the A’aninin Indian Tribe of Montana. From this Foreword: A refreshing insight into the challenging, and often troubling, aspect of the creation of Native art by non-Native artisans, Not Native American Art is a must-have for those interested in the complexity of the creation of Native art by both Native and non-Native artists.

The faking of Native American art objects has proliferated as their commercial value has increased, but even a century ago experts were warning that the faking of objects ranging from catlinite pipes to Chumash sculpture was rampant. Through a series of historical and contemporary case studies, Janet Catherine Berlo engages with troubling and sometimes confusing categories of inauthenticity.

Based on decades of research as well as interviews with curators, collectors, restorers, replica makers, re-enactors, and Native artists and cultural specialists, Not Native American Art examines the historical and social contexts within which people make replicas and fakes or even invent new objects that then become "traditional." Berlo follows the unexpected trajectories of such objects, including Northwest Coast carvings, "Navajo" rugs made in Mexico, Zuni mask replicas, Lakota-style quillwork, and Mimbres bowl forgeries. With engaging anecdotes, the book offers a rich and nuanced understanding of a surprisingly wide range of practices that makers have used to produce objects that are "not Native American art."  This book contains 42 colour illus., 22 b&w illus.